Cherokee wrote on 11/08/16 at 3:04am:
That appears to be the key to the question I was asking. Probably a bit of a CYA matter for the land planners, not an expectation that we have created as riders or a club. Thanks for the info.
You also have to take into consideration time to design and build trail only using volunteer labor. Mazzeppa Road Park had a grant applied for it by the Town of Mooresville. The club will take over duties of maintenance and repair when it's finished. As far as Uwharrie, the redo of Keyawee would have taking 4 times as long or longer to redo by hand.
It usually takes about 6-7 months to hand build/bench cut about 2 miles of trail. I can rough in a mile of trail in 3 weeks with a machine and hand finish work usually a months worth of Saturdays/Sundays. $4-$8 per linear foot is spot on for estimates.
When we had Bob Karriker build Laurel and Wildlife, he did it at a reduced rate of $1 per foot. He used the club's machines, took out his own insurance policy and we paid him as a contractor. That was paid for with a $75K RTP grant.
I, like you, feel that trail building has become a little too homogenized in certain cases and like to machine build as well as hand build. It really depends on what kind of experience you're looking to design/build.
Machine building is also a more predictable quanta, as well. With volunteers you never know who will or won't show up to work so it can be unpredictable especially when dealing with deadlines like we did with LNSP.